Unfortunately, not every parent is supportive of their child. Especially if that child excels in “their” particular domain.
Envy can manifest as a simple lack of support (withholding “earned” compliments and appreciation), as well as more serious and manipulative actions.
It is extremely important to understand that parent envy isn’t about you.
Parent envy takes many different forms. In my own life, for example, it has been the benchmark of my relationship with my mother. When I visited her last, within the day she had cut her hair (mine was short) and within the week she had ‘adopted’ my fashion style.
This is the same women, upon being told by her cocaine addicted boyfriend that we should have a threesome, who got mad at me. (For the record, I hadn’t done anything but be 16 years old and in his presence.)
“Come on” he said, “it’ll be like two Karens!”
Parent envy does not need to be extreme to be hurtful. My father, for instance, was completely supportive of my interest in dance. He was not supportive in the slightest, however, of my interest in singing.
As a classically trained musician, I thought that he would be the first to support and cheer me on yet I did not realize that I had unwittingly tread upon ‘his’ territory.
My focused attention to nuance and pitch and tone and breath elicited absolutely nothing. My vocal bodacity (7 octaves, baby!) for naught. I may as well have been caterwauling.
Realize that your parents are not perfect. This can be a great challenge. Our parents are our guides, our teachers. We love and respect and trust them, often giving them great deference. When they withhold their love, we feel as if we are to blame.
One of the steps in a parent-child relationship is the child’s pulling away, of setting new boundaries, of seeing and accepting that their parent is not a god. They are human beings with everything that entails.
They’ll make mistakes and act in their own interests and lose their temper. They’ll disappoint you as often as they’ll inspire you.
Know that none of it has to do with you. Their fear and insecurity is about their own stuff, you just happen to be in their sphere of influence.
Each person in your life interacts with you differently. Every friendship is unique, every romance is different…even your relationship with your parents will differ with each parent.
Each person is perceiving you through their own filters and experiences.
You are not crazy. The problem with parent envy is that it is often very subtle and hard to explain to others. They might think you are exaggerating or overreacting, oversensitive, irrational or imagining things.
You might start to second-guess yourself and be “better”. But, frankly, it’s a little like low-key racism or sexism…no one really believes it exists unless it happens to them. It can be that subtle.
Keep contact light. If the parent envy is very specific (like my dad and singing) then you can simply look elsewhere for support in this area. Don’t mention the offending topic or engage them in any way about it. Just excise it from your relationship. If they ask, be vague.
If the parent envy is general (as in the case of my mother) keep your general contact light. In this instance, they like you a whole lot better when you are nowhere around. (When you are absent, you are a testament to their awesome. When you are present, you are a direct challenge to it.)
In addition to being absent, I give my mother as little information as possible. Vague is a fantastic strategy in this instance as well.
Before I learned to be vague, my mother also wanted a law degree and started her own blog. Now I usually talk about Chris because my husband does not activate her “parent envy”.
Search for other avenues of more positive, unbiased feedback. (Or positively biased feedback!) Be they a mentor, a tutor, or a really good friend, have someone in your life whose sense of self-esteem has nothing to do with you.
Remind yourself that they have their own journey. Accept them as they are and recognize that this behavior will not likely change. They may never tell you how proud of you they are.
But even if their inner fears will not let them admit it, know that they are proud of you. In their deepest heart they love, appreciate, and celebrate you.






5 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 21, 2009 at 6:42 pm
positivelypresent
This is a great post about a topic that’s rarely written (or talked) about. I love the insights you’ve shared and I think that last point is especially important. We all must remember that we’re on our own paths and we can’t let parents’ (or anyone else’s) envy distract us from that.
hayden tompkins says:
It reminds me of what is said in “Fight Club” about the relationship between our parents and God.
July 21, 2009 at 8:32 pm
thenightwriterblog
Fwiw, my youngest daughter, Tiger Lilly, is a very gifted writer. She’ll likely sell a novel or story long before I even get a sniff. I’m not threatened in the least by her skill and I love reading her stuff (especially when she “steals” lines from me!).
Oh, and I’m back in the U.S., back in the U.S., back in the U.S. of A!
hayden tompkins says:
I knew we felt a little more awesome then usual!
It is wonderful that you are so supportive of her dreams and her gifts. And even Nobel Laureates and Pulitzer Prize winners want to make their parents proud.
July 22, 2009 at 12:01 am
pannonica
It’s only ok to kill your parents metaphorically, otherwise you might have to go to jail.
hayden tompkins says:
July 22, 2009 at 4:47 pm
janice
Jeez, I like your bold posts!! Your mum, among other things, must think you’re totally awesome to want to imitate you so much. But as a mum myself, I don’t know what I’d do to her if we ever crossed paths…
Your dad must realise you’re brilliant, too, if he feels so threatened.
As someone who’s old enough to be your mum, I just think you’re awesome. Full stop.
Like I once did, my own daughter writes, sings, draws, acts and plays guitar. And she’s more talented for her age than I ever was. I have to be very careful not to live vicariously and I also have to resist the urge to teach, warn, advise and pass on what I’ve learned from the mistakes I made and would love her to avoid. She’s also slim and gorgeous. Now that I do envy, in the most politically incorrect way possible!
hayden tompkins says:
I don’t often talk about her and I am taking a big risk doing so here, if she ever finds it. It is, in a way, easier to talk about my father. He raised me and most of the stuff that has happened in my life is related to that relationship and it’s fallout…plus he isn’t crazy. My mother has borderline personality and is, frankly, batshit insane.
Sooo. Basically, I almost never never talk about her.
Your daughter sounds fabulous! I think it is pretty human to have flashes of envy once in a while as long as they stay in the brain where they belong.
July 22, 2009 at 4:56 pm
Birdie
It made me wonder how this might manifest itself? For example, my mom paid her way through a few years of her post-secondary education, but didn’t finish. Sometimes I wonder if that’s partly why she refused to help with post-HS-school – to the point that I couldn’t fill out a FAFSA till I was 24. Maybe it’s not competing but “if I got this, this is what YOU will get…”? =/
hayden tompkins says:
Wow, even my dad didn’t interfere with my education.
P.S. Seriously, I could not believe you had to be 24!!!! I tried doing it without my father at first but it was impossible. They said I basically had to have been emancipated. Ugh. I hatehatehate our system of secondary education.